Session Information
Date: Tuesday, November 7, 2017
Title: Systemic Sclerosis, Fibrosing Syndromes and Raynaud's – Clinical Aspects and Therapeutics Poster III
Session Type: ACR Poster Session C
Session Time: 9:00AM-11:00AM
Background/Purpose: Relatively little data exist in the literature to characterize the differences between patients with scleroderma-associated isolated pulmonary arterial hypertension (SSc-PAH, WHO Group 1) and pulmonary hypertension that coexists with interstitial lung disease (SSc-ILD-PH, WHO Group 3). Our aim was to compare the characteristics of SSc-PAH and SSc-ILD-PH patients from the Cleveland Clinic Pulmonary Hypertension Database to help define differences that may exist between these two groups.
Methods: We performed a retrospective chart-review comparing demographic, laboratory, and hemodynamic data from a total of 176 patients (155 with SSc-PAH and 21 with SSc-ILD-PH) enrolled in the Cleveland Clinic Pulmonary Hypertension Database. The diagnosis of PAH was confirmed by right-heart cardiac catheterization (RHC). The diagnosis of SSc was confirmed by a rheumatologist and that of ILD was confirmed by a pulmonologist. Thirty-three variables were ultimately chosen for evaluation; the decision to include a given variable was based either on previous evidence in the literature that said variables were relevant in predicting outcomes in SSc-PAH or SSc-ILD-PH patients. Multivariate and univariate evaluations were performed using ANOVA, the Kruskal-Wallis test, Pearson’s chi-square test, and Fisher’s Exact test. A p-value of <0.05 was considered significant.
Results: Statistically significant differences between the SSc-PAH and SSc-ILD-PH groups were found for age, forced vital capacity (% estimated), pulmonary vascular resistance, cardiac index by thermodilution, and NT-proBNP level. Additionally, we observed that in our cohort SSc-ILD-PH patients tended to live longer than those with SSc-PAH. Among SSc-ILD-PH, the estimated median time-to-death was 13.19 years (95% CI: 3.79 – 20.72 years), whereas in SSc-PAH patients, the estimated median time-to-death was 4.89 years (95% CI: 4.01 – 6.98 years). However, this difference in survival was not statistically significant (P = 0.1743).
Factor |
Total |
SSc-PAH |
SSc-ILD-PH |
p-value |
BMI* |
28.2±7.6 |
28.1±7.2 |
28.9±10.3 |
0.64a |
Patient Age |
63.8±11.9 |
64.5±11.3 |
58.0±14.7 |
0.019a |
Forced Vital Capacity Percent* |
69.8±20.5 |
71.2±21.0 |
60.6±14.2 |
0.027a |
Forced Expiratory Vol Percent* |
69.7±19.9 |
70.8±20.4 |
61.6±14.4 |
0.047a |
Total Lung Capacity Percent* |
76.7±17.3 |
77.2±17.0 |
72.5±19.4 |
0.29a |
Ejection Fraction, TTE* |
57.9±6.6 |
57.8±6.4 |
58.7±8.3 |
0.55a |
Right Atrial Area, TTE* |
24.1±8.2 |
24.4±8.3 |
20.0±5.8 |
0.21a |
Systolic Blood Pressure* |
131.4±21.6 |
130.7±21.4 |
137.4±22.7 |
0.21a |
Diastolic Blood Pressure* |
77.9±13.4 |
77.7±13.9 |
79.6±8.7 |
0.57a |
Pulmonary Cap. Wedge Pressure* |
12.1±7.0 |
12.1±7.2 |
12.0±5.9 |
0.96a |
Pulmonary Vascular Resistance* |
8.0±5.2 |
8.4±5.3 |
5.2±3.8 |
0.013a |
Systemic Vascular Resistance* |
1644.7±678.3 |
1650.8±699.3 |
1590.7±465.5 |
0.74a |
Uric Acid Level* |
7.1±3.4 |
7.5±3.3 |
3.7±3.7 |
0.13a |
Walking Test Distance* |
272.9±105.3 |
269.4±108.7 |
295.1±79.8 |
0.32a |
FEV1/FVC Percent Ratio* |
78.1±9.6 |
77.8±9.6 |
80.2±9.9 |
0.28a |
Right Vent. Pressure, TTE* |
71.1±23.2 |
72.3±22.9 |
61.7±24.1 |
0.062a |
Cardiac Output (THERMO)* |
4.6±1.6 |
4.6±1.7 |
5.1±1.6 |
0.23a |
Cardiac Index (THERMO)* |
2.5±0.79 |
2.5±0.76 |
2.9±0.90 |
0.036a |
Cardiac Output (FICK)* |
4.7±1.6 |
4.6±1.6 |
4.8±1.2 |
0.72a |
Cardiac Index (FICK)* |
2.6±0.83 |
2.5±0.84 |
2.7±0.71 |
0.49a |
DLCO on PFT* |
29.0[0.48,45.0] |
29.0[0.49,46.0] |
32.0[0.43,42.0] |
0.59b |
C-Reactive Protein Level* |
1.00[0.40,2.8] |
1.2[0.45,2.9] |
0.60[0.30,1.7] |
0.24b |
NT-proBNP Level* |
1079.5[381.0,4099.0] |
1485.5[512.0,4248.5] |
187.0[110.0,597.0] |
0.002b |
Serum Creatinine Level* |
0.92[0.79,1.2] |
0.97[0.80,1.2] |
0.83[0.68,1.05] |
0.10b |
Serum Ferritin Level* |
96.8[35.0,227.0] |
95.8[35.0,227.0] |
105.2[85.0,178.6] |
0.84b |
Patient Gender |
|
|
|
0.68c |
. Female |
148(84.1) |
131(84.5) |
17(81.0) |
|
. Male |
28(15.9) |
24(15.5) |
4(19.0) |
|
Patient Race* |
|
|
|
0.006c |
. Caucasian |
149(86.1) |
135(88.8) |
14(66.7) |
|
. Other |
24(13.9) |
17(11.2) |
7(33.3) |
|
Smoking Status |
|
|
|
0.28c |
. No |
89(50.6) |
81(52.3) |
8(38.1) |
|
. Unknown |
30(17.0) |
27(17.4) |
3(14.3) |
|
. Yes |
57(32.4) |
47(30.3) |
10(47.6) |
|
IPF Status |
|
|
|
0.29c |
. No |
120(68.2) |
107(69.0) |
13(61.9) |
|
. Unknown |
33(18.8) |
30(19.4) |
3(14.3) |
|
. Yes |
23(13.1) |
18(11.6) |
5(23.8) |
|
ANA Status |
|
|
|
0.74c |
. Negative |
15(8.5) |
13(8.4) |
2(9.5) |
|
. Unknown |
55(31.3) |
50(32.3) |
5(23.8) |
|
. Positive |
106(60.2) |
92(59.4) |
14(66.7) |
|
*Data not available for all subjects. Missing values: BMI = 1, Forced Vital Capacity Percent = 9, Forced Expiratory Vol Percent = 9, Total Lung Capacity Percent = 36, Ejection Fraction, TTE = 10, Right Atrial Area, TTE = 99, Systolic Blood Pressure = 9, Diastolic Blood Pressure = 9, Pulmonary Cap. Wedge Pressure = 2, Pulmonary Vascular Resistance = 9, Systemic Vascular Resistance = 19, Uric Acid Level = 155, Walking Test Distance = 37, FEV1/FVC Percent Ratio = 10, Right Vent. Syst. Pressure, TTE = 8, Cardiac Output (THERMO) = 22, Cardiac Index (THERMO) = 22, Cardiac Output (FICK) = 21, Cardiac Index (FICK) = 21, DLCO on PFT = 30, C-Reactive Protein Level = 116, Brain Natriuretic Peptide = 80, NT-proBNP Level = 106, Serum Creatinine Level = 5, Serum Ferritin Level = 118, Patient Race = 3, NYHA class (at diagnosis) = 51, NYHA class (at 3 months) = 105, NYHA class (at 6 months) = 119. |
Conclusion: In our study, statistically significant differences were found between SSc-PAH and SSc-ILD-PH patients. The suggestion of longer survival in SSc-ILD-PH patients may be explained by some lurking variables that were not available for analysis, such as autoantibody subsets. SSc-PAH patients were older and possibly were more likely to have limited SSc with positive anti-centromere antibody, representing a subpopulation that is distinct from the SSc-ILD-PH patients. More research is necessary to elucidate these differences.
To cite this abstract in AMA style:
Hannan A, Dweik R, Highland KB, Heresi G, Tonelli A, Messner W, Chatterjee S. Comparison of Scleroderma Associated Isolated Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension and Pulmonary Hypertension with Concomitant Interstitial Lung Disease [abstract]. Arthritis Rheumatol. 2017; 69 (suppl 10). https://acrabstracts.org/abstract/comparison-of-scleroderma-associated-isolated-pulmonary-arterial-hypertension-and-pulmonary-hypertension-with-concomitant-interstitial-lung-disease/. Accessed .« Back to 2017 ACR/ARHP Annual Meeting
ACR Meeting Abstracts - https://acrabstracts.org/abstract/comparison-of-scleroderma-associated-isolated-pulmonary-arterial-hypertension-and-pulmonary-hypertension-with-concomitant-interstitial-lung-disease/